Hart's Tavern was an early roadside inn in what is now Patchogue, New York, and it is remembered primarily because George Washington stopped there for a meal during his tour of Long Island in 1790. [hmdb.org], [sites.google.com]
Washington's Visit
On April 22, 1790, while traveling across Long Island as the nation's first president, George Washington recorded in his diary that he "dined Harts Tavern in Brookhaven township." This diary entry is the strongest historical evidence for the tavern's existence and importance. [sites.google.com], [hmdb.org]
Washington wrote that after leaving the area of present-day Islip, he traveled east on the South Road and stopped at Hart's Tavern before continuing north across Long Island toward Setauket. [sites.google.com]
Who Owned the Tavern?
Historians generally believe the inn was operated by Gilbert Hart, who appears in the 1790 federal census for the Brookhaven area. Evidence suggests he may have run his home as a tavern or inn serving travelers along the south shore road. [history.pmlib.org], [sites.google.com]
The Mystery of Its Location
One of the most intriguing aspects of Hart's Tavern is that the exact location has never been conclusively established. Most historians place it near the western edge of present-day Lakeview Cemetery on Main Street (now Montauk Highway) in Patchogue. [sites.google.com], [hmdb.org]
In 1925, the Daughters of the American Revolution, specifically the Col. Josiah Smith Chapter, erected a marker identifying the approximate site of the tavern. [hmdb.org]
In 1999, the Greater Patchogue Historical Society installed another marker commemorating Washington's visit. [hmdb.org]
Modern ground-penetrating radar investigations have reportedly found evidence of a buried structure near the marked site, lending support to the traditional location. [lindaleuzzi.com]
Hart's Tavern Today
The original building no longer exists. However, two historical markers near the entrance to Lakeview Cemetery commemorate the site and the visit of George Washington. These markers have made Hart's Tavern one of Patchogue's most notable Revolutionary-era landmarks. [hmdb.org], [hmdb.org]
A Lesser-Known Detail
Some accounts note that Thomas Jefferson may also have stopped at Hart's Tavern during his travels on Long Island, though Washington's diary provides the most firmly documented visit. [lindaleuzzi.com]
In short, Hart's Tavern was a late 18th-century inn, probably operated by Gilbert Hart, that earned its place in history because George Washington dined there during his 1790 Long Island tour. Although the building has vanished, its approximate site remains marked and celebrated in Patchogue. [history.pmlib.org], [hmdb.org], [hmdb.org]